The 2024 NFL preseason has been an illuminating period for evaluating the impact of first-round rookies, offering glimpses of potential future stars and solidifying player narratives for the upcoming season.
Quarterbacks Show Glimpses of Potential
At the forefront of rookie evaluations were the quarterbacks, each showcasing varying degrees of readiness and potential. Caleb Williams, a highly anticipated talent, completed 50% of his throws while averaging an impressive 8.5 yards per attempt over 42 snaps. Despite the modest completion percentage, his ability to stretch the field was evident, hinting at his potential to evolve into a dynamic playmaker.
Jayden Daniels stood out with remarkable efficiency, completing 12 of his 15 attempts for 123 yards. Though he didn't record any touchdowns or interceptions, his ability to manage the game and maintain composure under center was clear. Similarly, Drake Maye displayed a balanced skill set, improving as the preseason progressed. He threw for 66 yards on 8 of 14 passing in the first two games and capped off the preseason with 13 completions on 20 attempts for 126 yards and a touchdown against the Commanders.
Michael Penix Jr. and Bo Nix mirrored each other’s performances, with each completing 9 of 16 passes for 104 yards, displaying steady, if unspectacular, presences in their appearances.
Emerging Wide Receivers and Dynamic Plays
Wide receivers also had their moments to shine. Malik Nabers caught attention with four receptions totaling 54 yards in his second preseason game, showing his ability to be a reliable target. Rome Odunze, albeit in a limited showing, recorded a significant 45-yard catch, demonstrating his potential for big plays. Meanwhile, Brian Thomas Jr. showcased consistent production across the preseason, accumulating 93 yards on three catches.
Xavier Worthy reminded fans of the volatility that can accompany an emerging talent. While he scored a touchdown, he also fumbled, a reminder of the learning curve many rookies face.
Offensive Linemen and Defensive Standouts
Offensive linemen and defensive players equally provided compelling performances. Joe Alt’s progression was particularly noteworthy; after a challenging start, he showed significant improvement in pass protection during his second preseason game. Olu Fashanu also had a mixed but promising debut, initially allowing pressure on his first professional pass-pro set but compensating with effective run blocking thereafter.
Defensively, Laiatu Latu made a statement with a sack among his 13 pass-rushing snaps in Indianapolis's third game, establishing himself as a potential menace for opposing quarterbacks. Byron Murphy and Dallas Turner each generated two pressures on 20 pass-rushing snaps, highlighting their potential roles in disrupting the opposing offense.
On the other hand, not every rookie found immediate success. Chop Robinson failed to register any pressures over two games, a reminder of the challenges rookies often face in transitioning to the professional level. However, Quinyon Mitchell’s standout performance in the secondary, allowing just two catches for eight yards, exemplified his lockdown potential.
Nate Wiggins further emphasized the depth of talent in the rookie cornerback class. He recorded three pass breakups in one drive and allowed no receptions on two targets in the final game, signaling his readiness to compete at a high level from the outset.
Special Teams and Versatile Contributors
Special teams and versatile contributors also made their presence felt. J.C. Latham’s balance and power in the run game, paired with his agility in pass protection, established him as a multifaceted asset on the offensive line. Graham Barton’s effective run blocking and Tyler Guyton’s positive signs on special teams across two matchups underscored the importance of versatility and depth on an NFL roster.
The 2024 NFL preseason has provided invaluable insights into the preparedness and potential of these first-round rookies. As the regular season approaches, fans and analysts alike will watch with keen interest to see how these early impressions translate into sustained success on the field. While the preseason is only a preliminary stage, the performances of Williams, Daniels, Maye, Nabers, Latu, and Wiggins, among others, suggest that the future of the league is in capable hands.